Active fund managers face increasing challenges as new data reveals their consistent underperformance against benchmarks. According to S&P Global, 73% of active managers fail to outperform their benchmarks after just one year. Over time, these odds worsen significantly. By five years, 95.5% miss their targets, and after 15 years, none succeed, according to Charley Ellis, a pioneer in market indexing.
The growth of passive funds is a crucial factor driving this trend. As more investors flock to index funds, some industry insiders express concerns that this shift could threaten the active management business. However, Ellis argues that such fears are unfounded. He believes that technology has leveled the playing field in the markets, complicating the task of gaining an edge over other traders.
Ellis stresses the importance of choosing Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) wisely.
"What you have to be really positive about is the increase of ETFs that are available and a steady reduction in the fees that are being charged," said Ellis.
He warns investors to be cautious with leveraged ETFs, which can lead to "explosive upside but also explosive downside."
Despite the challenges, the active management space is far from extinction. Dave Nadig, an ETF industry expert, concurs that active managers will persist.
"We just had the best year for active management inflows that we'd ever had," Nadig noted.
Active ETFs have seen record inflows, continuing to attract investor money. In January alone, these funds maintained their hot streak in capturing investor interest.
"It isn't that anybody thinks active management shouldn't exist, but the vast majority of flows are coming from fairly unsophisticated individual investors going into big indexes and big target data funds," added Nadig.
Ellis's insights highlight how technology serves as a great equalizer in today's markets. With everyone having access to similar tools and information, gaining a competitive advantage becomes increasingly difficult.
"The ironic reason that active managers underperform is that they're all so good at what they're trying to do, they cancel each other out," Ellis explained.
This dynamic creates a scenario akin to "playing poker with all the cards face up."
Ellis's new book, "Rethinking Investing – A Very Short Guide to Very Long-Term Investing," sheds light on these complexities and offers guidance for investors navigating this landscape. He emphasizes the importance of looking beyond short-term performance and considering long-term investment strategies.
While passive funds remain dominant due to their lower fees and broad appeal, Ellis acknowledges that active management remains possible—though identifying successful managers in advance is challenging.
"Active management is possible, you'll just never find it in advance," Nadig concluded.
Leave a Reply