GB News has emerged victorious in a significant legal challenge against the UK broadcasting regulator, Ofcom, in a case concerning the role of politicians in news programming. The High Court judgment, delivered by Mrs Justice Collins Rice, ruled that Ofcom’s previous decisions regarding the network’s programming were unlawful, marking a historic defeat for the regulatory body.
The case revolved around the State of the Nation shows hosted by Sir Jacob Rees-Mogg. Ofcom had concluded last year that these programs breached its code, which states that politicians typically cannot act as newsreaders or interviewers unless "exceptionally" justified. However, the court found that Ofcom had misapplied Rule 5.3 of its code, which pertains specifically to news programs and does not extend to current affairs shows like those hosted by Sir Jacob.
In her ruling, Mrs Justice Collins Rice stated, "I am minded to quash the two decisions in this case, and remit them to be reconsidered by Ofcom, subject to whatever further procedure may be fairly indicated." This judgment not only vindicates GB News but also raises critical questions about Ofcom's adherence to its own regulations.
Angelos Frangopoulos, CEO of GB News, expressed satisfaction with the outcome, stating that the decision "vindicates GB News' position as the fearless defender of free speech in the United Kingdom." He further urged the government and Parliament to consider the implications of Ofcom's failures in oversight.
Ofcom acknowledged the court's guidance and stated its intention to review and consult on potential changes to its broadcasting code. They noted that the rulings had indicated that "news was, therefore, not presented with due impartiality." In response to the High Court’s findings, Ofcom confirmed it would take steps to clarify the regulations regarding politicians presenting news.
The judicial review centered on five rulings made by Ofcom in March last year. This outcome marks a pivotal moment in media regulation, as it represents the first time Ofcom has lost such a case. Additionally, the court ordered Ofcom to cover GB News' legal costs incurred during the proceedings.
GB News contended throughout the investigation that their programming did not violate the broadcasting code. They asserted that Ofcom's conclusions were misguided and contradicted established precedents.
Leave a Reply