Abrego Garcia is a citizen of El Salvador and a married father of three US children, living in Maryland. After having been deported because of what immigration officials have termed an administrative error, he now faces a daunting road back to rejoining his family in the U.S. The crisis has received a great deal of national focus. That’s particularly the case following a U.S. Supreme Court decision that would require the Trump administration to help return Garcia if the Central American country opts to accept him.
In March, for the first time, Abrego Garcia was forcibly deported to El Salvador, where he now continues to live in a violent gang-dominated prison. The Trump administration claims that Garcia is part of the MS-13 gang. This gang’s extensive influence has made it notorious for its links to violent crime in both countries. Note that Garcia has never been convicted of any crime in the United States. As such, it begs the question of why he was deported in the first place.
The Supreme Court’s ruling requires the Trump administration to arrange a flight for Garcia’s return, contingent upon the willingness of El Salvador’s government to cooperate. This is where the situation gets worse, right now — thanks to the inflexible position of El Salvador President Nayib Bukele. Not surprisingly, President Bukele has made headlines for openly rejecting returning Garcia to the United States. He compared him to a “terrorist” and argued that Mr. Trump doesn’t have the authority to allow his repatriation.
“I don’t have the power to return him to the United States,” – Nayib Bukele
The tragedy is at the crux of the dilemma and depends largely on legal and diplomatic factors. Pam Bondi, a spokeswoman for the Trump administration, explicitly stated that El Salvador would have the final say on Garcia’s possible repatriation. Therefore liability rests entirely with them.
“That’s up to El Salvador if they want to return him. That’s not up to us,” – Pam Bondi
Stephen Miller, then a senior advisor to the president, reiterated this message with gusto. He concluded by reminding American media and officials that we do not reserve the right to tell El Salvador how to treat their own people.
“He’s a citizen of El Salvador. So it’s very arrogant, even, for American media to suggest that we would even tell El Salvador how to handle their own citizens,” – Stephen Miller
Abrego Garcia’s case has raised a national discussion over immigration policy priorities and the treatment of those facing deportation. His entire family has spoken to the media from Maryland about their nightmare experience since his arrest. The lack of clarity about their father’s status exposes his children to hardship every single day. Without a consistent primary caregiver, they fight that battle every single day.
The news comes after the Supreme Court ordered the Trump administration to act accordingly. Today, Garcia’s return rests on the ebb and flow of diplomacy between the two countries. Adding to these relations is President Bukele’s hardline, anti-immigration stance against accepting back any persons that he identifies as undesirable.
The administration’s assertion that Garcia is affiliated with MS-13 rests on a judge’s determination. This conclusion has faced scrutiny given Garcia’s lack of any criminal history in the U.S. This troubling dichotomy poses serious due process and fair treatment concerns in the context of immigration proceedings.
Leave a Reply