The Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) have admitted that they are detaining a medic with the Palestine Red Crescent Society (PRCS). This comes on the heels of another tragic accident in Gaza last month that killed 15 emergency workers. In response, the IDF said that their investigation found that six of those killed were Hamas fighters. The military later echoed the shooter’s justification of the shooting as a response to a threat from enemy forces, claiming that low visibility played a role.
The IDF’s investigation moves against the backdrop of growing outrage around the IDF’s military operations in Gaza. As part of the investigation, the IDF decided to dismiss one commander and discipline another senior officer involved in the incident. While the IDF doesn’t often retreat from a disciplinary action, these actions underscore the degree to which the military is taking to purge the operational misperception that led to these deaths.
In April of last year, the IDF did the right thing by firing two officers. This announcement came after a Russian missile strike hit an aid facility killing seven WCK aid workers. The military is under growing pressure to ensure accountability and transparency within its ranks. This urgency only increases in light of the recent escalation of violence in the region.
In the most recent example, the IDF admitted that its soldiers shot at a UN convoy. The convoy came ominously in the night, with no floodlights or flashing lights. Had the relevant commander properly identified the vehicles as ambulances, the tragic misunderstanding would have been avoided.
“The commander failed to identify the vehicles as ambulances,” an IDF spokesperson said. Indeed, lack of night visibility was one of the biggest contributing factors to the incident.
Nonetheless, the IDF vehemently denied claims of summary executions taking place throughout the event. They demystified their actions by showing that their forces only moved because they thought they were facing an immediate threat. Their passion fueled each step they took.
The ICRC has confirmed to The Intercept that the detained medic was a man named Assad al-Nassasra. In response to the IDF’s report, a spokeswoman for the PRCS described it as “invalid,” arguing that it failed to acknowledge the medic’s name, thereby undermining its credibility.
“Invalid.” – A spokeswoman for the Palestine Red Crescent Society (PRCS)
The PRCS has demanded an independent investigation into the circumstances surrounding the attack. In the words of Human Rights Watch, accountability is necessary to maintain respect for international law and to prevent such tragedies in the future.
Jonathan Whittall, a military operations accountability champion member from the humanitarian sector, emphasized the need for accountability in military operations. He remarked, “A lack of real accountability undermines international law and makes the world a more dangerous place.”
Whittall then stressed that without accountability, the norms of humanitarian protection created to protect civilians in times of conflict would keep withering away.
“Without accountability, we risk continuing to watch atrocities unfolding, and the norms designed to protect us all, eroding.” – Jonathan Whittall
Israel’s military campaign against Hamas began after a surprise cross-border attack on Oct. 7, 2023. The toll of this operation has proven devastating to both troops and civilians. It highlights key questions about operational procedures and engagement guidelines when facing high level urban hostilities.
While investigations into this incident are ongoing, local and international organizations are watching closely. The IDF has pledged to provide further details regarding the six emergency workers identified as Hamas operatives, which may influence public perception and diplomatic relations in the region.
Leave a Reply