In a significant political move, former President Donald Trump has dismissed two Democratic board members of the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA). Their terminations, effective immediately, were the first message received by the Commission late Tuesday evening via email. This action is part of Trump’s broader strategy to remove Democratic officials from key regulatory positions, including recent efforts to oust commissioners at the Federal Trade Commission.
In 2019, Trump broke this pattern when he appointed Todd Harper to serve on the NCUA during his first term. Since 2021, Todd has been the board’s chair, and a 2022 reconfirmation process locked in his term—now typically eight years long—until 2027. Nomination and confirmation President Joe Biden nominated Otsuka, and the Senate confirmed the nomination in 2023. Otsuka’s term is scheduled to run through 2029.
The abrupt dismissals have raised concerns about the agency’s regulatory equilibrium. Both Harper and Otsuka have responded to these recent developments. Civil society co-lead Roger Harper harshly condemned the decision. As he put it, “This politically motivated, ill-conceived decision to terminate me before the completion of my term undermines the critical regulatory balance and will hurt consumers.”
Otsuka went a step further to show her displeasure. She described the firings as “yet another politically motivated attempt to undermine the rule of law and to blatantly ignore Congress and our democratic values.”
White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt came to Trump’s defense. As to the separation of powers argument, she claimed, “President Trump is the chief executive of the executive branch and certainly has the right to fire anyone he wishes.” This quote highlights the administration’s position on executive power as we continue to hear talk about regulatory independence.
The dismissals have brought attention to a related matter currently before the U.S. Supreme Court, which may further clarify the boundaries of executive power in terms of appointing and removing officials from independent regulatory agencies.
Since leaving office, Trump has taken radical steps to remake federal labor boards. He’s going after regulatory agencies too, in a careful, strategic move for the long haul. In March, he took a courageous step to kick two Democratic commissioners from the Federal Trade Commission. This action makes clear his continuing commitment to ensuring independence at these crucially important oversight bodies.
As reactions unfold and legal considerations are assessed, the implications of these firings on consumer protection and regulatory practices remain to be seen. This new amendment marks an enormous change in the continuing struggle between limited versus expansive political philosophies in front of federal regulatory agencies.
Leave a Reply