In a significant legal victory, a Washington D.C. judge has ruled in favor of Metropolitan AME, a historic Black church, barring the Proud Boys from selling merchandise that bears its name or symbols without the church's permission. This decision comes after the Proud Boys failed to pay an earlier $2.8 million judgment for vandalizing a Black Lives Matter sign outside the church in December 2020. The ruling not only allows Metropolitan AME to seize money earned from the sale of the Proud Boys trademark but also serves as a potential precedent for other organizations fighting against hate and extremism.
The Proud Boys, a far-right group known for their involvement in the January 6, 2021 riot at the U.S. Capitol, face increasing legal challenges. Henry "Enrique" Tarrio, a leader of the group, was charged with the vandalism incident and has announced plans to appeal the court's trademark decision. He expressed his view on the ruling, stating, "You can't kill an idea. You can't trademark an idea and you can't sue an idea."
Metropolitan AME has been at the forefront of civil rights activism for many years, hosting various events, including a recent rally to protect diversity efforts under the Trump administration. The church's decision to pursue legal action against the Proud Boys is seen as a strategic move to reclaim and repurpose the group's brand while highlighting ongoing social justice initiatives. Lamar, a representative of the church, remarked, "So when they came and vandalized our property, our ancestors stood up in us and we said, ‘No, we will not shrink.’"
The ruling grants Metropolitan AME the authority to seize profits from any sale, transfer, or license of the Proud Boys trademark. This financial leverage aims to offset the damages incurred from the vandalism while supporting the church's broader mission. In response to the judgment, Tarrio commented on its impact on his organization: "It really doesn't mean anything specifically to me or the guys because they could take the trademark."
The church has launched a project on its website that supports social justice work both locally and nationally. This initiative includes a donation page and a store featuring black T-shirts emblazoned with gold letters reading "Stay Black." William Lamar emphasized the importance of this victory by saying, "We want wide appeal because the people who are celebrating with us … need this moment of hope."
Experts believe that this legal outcome could inspire other groups beyond faith institutions to take similar actions against hate groups. Margaret Huang noted, "This win for the church is a symbol of how we can push back." She also drew parallels with a previous case where the Southern Poverty Law Center secured a $2.5 million judgment against a Kentucky-based Ku Klux Klan group in 2008, which helped dismantle their operations. "At the time of that victory, many people in the country felt that the KKK was immune from accountability," Huang added.
The Proud Boys have been a controversial figure in American politics, particularly due to their participation in high-profile events like the Capitol riot. Tarrio was serving a 22-year federal prison sentence for seditious conspiracy related to this event until President Trump pardoned him last month alongside nearly 1,600 others. His presence in these legal battles underscores the ongoing tension between extremist groups and their opposition.
While Tarrio remains defiant about the group's ideology and its commercialization, he acknowledges potential risks associated with their merchandise being widely available: "There's a lot of people that want to be us that it would be a danger to go ahead and put Proud Boys merchandise out for sale because then anybody can buy it."
Metropolitan AME's triumph over the Proud Boys could pave the way for other organizations to stand against extremist groups. The church's proactive approach in legally challenging and potentially repurposing the Proud Boys' brand highlights its commitment to social justice and community empowerment.
Leave a Reply