Mortgage rates have been on an upward trajectory in recent months, creating challenges for prospective homebuyers. Despite the Federal Reserve's efforts to cut interest rates, the cost of borrowing for a home has increased significantly. This shift has left many potential buyers and market analysts concerned about the future of the housing market.
For instance, the typical homebuyer paid $406,100 for an existing home in November, marking a 5% increase from $387,800 a year earlier. Rates on a 30-year fixed mortgage soared above 7% in the week ending January 16, according to Freddie Mac data. Such increases have led to worries about the affordability of homes and the overall vitality of the housing market.
Mortgage rates are more closely tied to the yield on 10-year U.S. Treasury bonds than to the Federal Reserve's benchmark interest rate. The current spread between these rates is about 2.4 percentage points, which is roughly 0.7 points higher than the historical average. Lenders typically price mortgages at a premium over 10-year Treasury yields, contributing to this wider spread.
"Anything over 7%, the market is dead," said Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody's.
This phenomenon is not just a statistical concern but also a practical one, as high mortgage rates deter potential buyers. As Zandi puts it, "No one is going to buy," highlighting the impact of these rates on consumer behavior.
In contrast, savers can still find attractive returns elsewhere, such as in money market funds, high-yield bank savings accounts, or certificates of deposit, which offer around 4% to 5% returns. This availability of alternative investment options further complicates the decision for consumers considering entering the housing market.
The Federal Reserve's policy shifts have included reducing its benchmark rate three times over a recent period by a full percentage point. However, even with these reductions, mortgage rates remain unlikely to dip back to 6% until 2026. This projection poses significant implications for those looking to buy homes or refinance existing mortgages.
"That's not something you should gamble with in the market," advised Lee Baker, a certified financial planner based in Atlanta and a member of CNBC's Financial Advisor Council.
The historical context reveals that from 1990 to 2019, the premium or "spread" between mortgage rates and Treasury yields was about 1.7 percentage points on average. The current spread of approximately 2.4 points indicates a notable deviation from past norms, complicating the affordability landscape for homebuyers.
"You're taking a gamble," Baker added, emphasizing the risks that current market conditions pose to potential buyers.
With mortgage rates having been below 3% as recently as late 2021, the rapid ascent in these rates has caught many off-guard. The need for rates to get closer to 6% or below is critical to "see the housing market come back to life," according to Zandi.
For consumers holding a 30-year, $300,000 fixed mortgage at 5%, monthly payments would amount to approximately $1,610 in principal and interest. Such figures highlight the financial burden imposed by elevated mortgage rates. Those aspiring to purchase homes are advised to consider making significant down payments to reduce their mortgage size and ensure it fits more comfortably within their monthly budget.
Joe Seydl, senior markets economist at J.P. Morgan Private Bank, expressed concerns about how high mortgage rates are "exacerbating the housing affordability challenge."
As Treasury yields rise, the Federal Reserve may lower borrowing costs more slowly and could potentially raise them again if necessary. This dynamic adds uncertainty for those navigating the housing market and underscores the importance of strategic financial planning.
Leave a Reply